Your Finance GuideFind a vetted broker
Novated lease vs car loan

Novated lease vs car loan: which costs less?

A novated lease is paid from your pre-tax salary through your employer and the financier claims back the GST on the car, while a car loan is paid from after-tax income but is yours alone and not tied to your job. For a battery-electric car under the FBT threshold the lease usually wins: the novated lease calculator estimates about $5,038 a year on a $55,000 EV for someone on $120,000. For a petrol or diesel car, FBT takes most of the saving, about $1,984 at the same price, and fees can tip it to the loan. Compare the full-term after-tax cost of both quotes, not the fortnightly figure.

Novated lease vs car loan vs finance lease, side by side

 Novated leaseCar loanFinance lease
Who can get oneEmployees whose employer offers salary packagingAnyone who meets the lender's criteriaA business, for a car it uses in the business
Paid fromPre-tax salary, through payrollAfter-tax incomeBusiness income; payments deductible for the business-use share
GST on the carClaimed back by the financierYou pay itThe lessor claims it; a GST-registered business claims the GST in each payment
Running costsBundled into the pre-tax deductionPaid separately, after taxPaid by the business, deductible for business use
FBTExempt for eligible EVs; post-tax contributions on other carsNot applicableOnly if the business provides the car to an employee for private use
Income statementShows a reportable fringe benefit (can affect HELP and some payments)No effectNo effect unless an employee has the car
If you change jobsMove the lease to the new employer or take over the paymentsNo effectNot tied to a job
At the endResidual due (28.13% of cost on a five-year lease, plus GST): pay, refinance or tradeNothing, unless you chose a balloonResidual due (at least the ATO minimum): pay to own, refinance or trade
Usually suitsBattery-electric cars under the FBT thresholdNo salary packaging, a likely job change, or a petrol car where fees eat a small lease savingBusinesses that want lower payments and to own the car at the end

Finance and operating leases for business are compared in car leasing: novated, finance and operating leases.

What does a car loan cost per month?

Monthly principal and interest repayments over 5 years, by loan amount and interest rate
Loan amountMonthly repayment at
6.5%p.a.8.5%p.a.10.5%p.a.
$45,000$880$923$967
$60,000$1,174$1,231$1,290
$75,000$1,467$1,539$1,612

Illustrative monthly principal and interest repayments over 5 years, before fees and charges. Rates are examples, not offers; your rate depends on the lender and your circumstances. 6.5%, 8.5% and 10.5% p.a. are illustrative rates, not lender offers or comparison rates; check each lender's comparison rate before you compare. The lease side, by car price, is on the novated lease guide. Use the car loan calculator.

For the lease side, see novated lease finance by car price: on the same five-year term, a lease finances the GST-exclusive price and leaves a residual, so its monthly finance figure is lower but a lump sum falls due at the end.

Calculator

Car loan repayment estimate

Loan amount$50,000
$10,000$100,000
Interest rate8.50% p.a.
5.00% p.a.15.00% p.a.
Loan term5 years
1 year7 years
Monthly repayment
$1,025.83

Car loan lenders to compare against a lease quote

If the lease does not win after tax, these lenders publish secured and green car loans. Several publish discounts for electric vehicles.

Car loan lenders to compare against a lease quote: each lender's type, the products it offers and its current rate
Commonwealth Bank of AustraliaMajor bankProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate:
6.79%p.a.
8.20% p.a. comparison rate*
Secured Fixed Rate Car Loan, Secured Fixed Rate Car Loan, secured by the car being bought: from rate for excellent credit (rates up to 11.29% p.a.); comparison on a $30,000 loan over 5 years.
Westpac Banking CorporationMajor bankProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
  • EV / Green
Current rate:
6.49%p.a.
7.90% p.a. comparison rate*
Car Loan Secured, Car Loan for petrol, diesel or LPG cars, fixed rate, secured by the car: from rate; the rate offered depends on your credit assessment.
Bank AustraliaCustomer-ownedProducts:
  • EV / Green
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate:
6.29%p.a.
6.29% p.a. comparison rate*
Clean Energy Car Loan, Electric Vehicle Loan, fixed rate, secured, new electric vehicles; establishment fee waived for fully electric vehicles; comparison on a $30,000 secured loan over 5 years.
Liberty FinancialNon-bankProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate:
8.99%p.a.
10.65% p.a. comparison rate*
Liberty Drive Secured, Flexible car loan, secured, new and used cars: from rate; comparison on a $30,000 new-car loan over 5 years with no balloon.
MoneyMeSpecialistProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
Current rate:
6.24%p.a.
7.13% p.a. comparison rate*
MoneyMe Secured Car Loan, Secured car loan, variable rate, new or used vehicles: from rate for excellent credit history (maximum 26.35% p.a.); $12.50 monthly fee.
Now FinanceSpecialistProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
Current rate:
7.59%p.a.
8.43% p.a. comparison rate*
NF Secured Car Loan (Tier 1), Vehicle Loan secured by the vehicle, new or used: from rate (rates up to 15.39% p.a.); establishment fee up to $595.
PlentiSpecialistProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
  • EV / Green
Current rate:
7.99%p.a.
9.78% p.a. comparison rate*
Plenti Car Loan (Tier 1), Secured car loan, new or demo vehicle, homeowner with exceptional credit: from rate (rates up to 12.99% p.a.); comparison on $30,000 over 60 months including a $14.90 monthly fee.
National Australia BankMajor bankProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate: NAB rate card (opens in a new tab)
BankSAMajor-bank brandProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate: BankSA rate card (opens in a new tab)
IMB BankCustomer-ownedProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate: IMB rate card (opens in a new tab)
Show all 14 lenders
Car loan lenders to compare against a lease quote, continued
Newcastle Permanent (Newcastle Greater Mutual Group)Customer-ownedProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
Current rate: Newcastle Permanent rate card (opens in a new tab)
Teachers Mutual BankCustomer-ownedProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate: Teachers Mutual rate card (opens in a new tab)
Pepper MoneyNon-bankProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
  • Secured (used vehicle)
Current rate: Pepper Money rate card (opens in a new tab)
Angle FinanceSpecialistProducts:
  • Secured (new vehicle)
Current rate: Angle Finance rate card (opens in a new tab)

Inclusion is editorial reference, not a recommendation. Rates change often, so we only show a rate we captured from the lender's own page in the last 60 days, with a link to that page; otherwise we link to the lender's rate card where it publishes one. The broker you are matched with compares the lenders on their own panel.

See all 20 car loan lenders

* WARNING: This comparison rate is true only for the examples given and may not include all fees and charges. Different terms, fees or other loan amounts might result in a different comparison rate. Car loan comparison rates are based on a secured loan of $30,000 over 5 years.

Novated lease vs car loan at a glance
  • A novated lease is paid from pre-tax salary and saves the GST on the car; a car loan is paid after tax
  • For a battery-electric car under the FBT threshold, the calculator estimates about $5,038 a year on a $55,000 EV and $120,000 salary
  • For a petrol, diesel or plug-in hybrid car, FBT takes most of the saving (about $1,984 at the same price), so fees can tip it to the car loan
  • A lease depends on your employer and your job; a car loan does not
  • Draft law released in September 2026 would narrow the EV exemption for commitments from 1 April 2027

How a novated lease works, compared with a car loan

A car loan is between you and a lender: you borrow, buy the car and repay from your take-home pay. A novated lease involves three parties, you, your employer and the finance company, and the arrangement flows like this:

  1. You choose a car, new or used, any make and model
  2. Finance company purchases the car, they own the vehicle during the lease term
  3. Three-way agreement signed, a “deed of novation” is signed by all three parties
  4. Employer deducts from your salary, lease payments and budgeted running costs come from your pre-tax salary each pay cycle
  5. At lease end, pay the residual value to own the car, refinance, trade in, or start a new lease on a different car

The “novation” means your employer takes on the obligation to make payments on your behalf from your salary. If you leave that employer, the obligation reverts to you personally, or you can novate the lease to a new employer. A car loan never involves your employer at all.

Which costs less: the worked comparison

The novated lease calculator compares a lease with paying for the same car's finance and running costs from after-tax pay, which is what a car loan at the same rate does. On its assumptions (a $120,000 salary, a 5-year term at an indicative 6.5% p.a., the 28.13% residual and the 2026-27 tax rates), a $55,000 FBT-exempt battery-electric car saves about $5,038 a year.

Change the car to petrol or diesel at the same price and the saving shrinks to about $1,984 a year: no exemption applies and FBT is covered from after-tax pay. That is small enough for a provider's fees, a lease rate above the loan rate or a marked-up car price to tip the comparison to the car loan. A car priced above the fuel-efficient threshold, and a plug-in hybrid arranged after 1 April 2025, are treated like the petrol car. A loan at a higher rate than the lease moves the comparison the other way.

EVs and the draft law
  • Battery-electric and hydrogen fuel cell cars under the fuel-efficient threshold ($91,661 for 2026-27) are FBT exempt today
  • Treasury's September 2026 exposure draft (proposed law, not yet passed) keeps the full exemption for commitments before 1 April 2027, then only for cars of $75,000 or less to 31 March 2029, then a 25% discount
  • On the calculator, a $85,000 EV saves about $6,904 a year today but about $2,035 under the draft's 25% discount, which narrows the gap to a car loan
  • What the draft law means for a novated lease

Running costs: bundled or paid yourself

A fully maintained novated lease bundles the following costs into your pre-tax salary deduction; with a car loan you pay them yourself from after-tax income:

  • Fuel or electricity charging, budgeted based on your estimated annual kilometres
  • Comprehensive insurance, arranged through the lease provider
  • Registration and CTP, renewal costs included in the budget
  • Scheduled servicing, manufacturer-recommended services covered
  • Tyre replacement, budgeted based on expected wear
  • Roadside assistance, where the package includes it

Budgeted running costs are reconciled against what you actually spend, so check how the provider handles any surplus or shortfall.

When a car loan is the better choice

  • Your employer does not offer salary packaging
  • The car is petrol, diesel or a plug-in hybrid, or priced above the fuel-efficient threshold, and the lease's fees or rate eat the smaller saving
  • You expect to change jobs, or your income may drop, during the term
  • A reportable fringe benefit would raise your HELP repayments or affect a payment you receive
  • The lease quote carries a marked-up car price or high fees that eat the tax saving

When a novated lease is the better choice

  • A battery-electric car under the threshold, with a commitment that keeps the full exemption
  • A stable job with an employer that offers salary packaging
  • A marginal tax rate high enough for pre-tax deductions to be worth having
  • A provider whose car price and fees you have checked against a quote of your own

WARNING: This comparison rate is true only for the examples given and may not include all fees and charges. Different terms, fees or other loan amounts might result in a different comparison rate. Comparison rates are calculated on a secured loan of $150,000 over 25 years for home loans and a loan of $30,000 over 5 years for car and personal loans, unless the lender states another basis. Business loans and equipment finance for a business purpose have no mandatory comparison rate.

Novated Lease vs Car Loan FAQs

Is a novated lease better than a car loan?
For a battery-electric car under the FBT threshold, usually yes: the novated lease calculator estimates about $5,038 a year on a $55,000 EV for someone on $120,000, against a loan at the same rate. For a petrol or diesel car the saving is much smaller, about $1,984 at the same price, and provider fees or a higher lease rate can tip it to the loan. Compare the full-term after-tax cost of both quotes, including running costs, not the fortnightly figure.
Is a novated lease cheaper than a car loan for a petrol car?
Sometimes, but by much less than for an EV. Without the EV exemption, FBT applies and is normally covered by paying part of the package from after-tax salary (the employee contribution method), which removes much of the income tax saving: the calculator estimates about $1,984 a year on a $55,000 petrol car, before provider fees. The GST saving on the car and running costs remains, so get both quotes and compare the total after-tax cost over the full term.
What is the 1.5 rule when leasing a car?
There is no "1.5 rule" in Australian tax law or ATO guidance; it comes from US car-leasing advice. What Australian rules do set is the minimum residual: 28.13% of the car's cost on a five-year lease (ATO ID 2002/1004). Judge a lease on its full-term after-tax cost, including the residual and fees, against a car loan quote.
What is the biggest downside to leasing a car?
For a novated lease, it ties the car to your job: if you leave, the payments come back to you from after-tax pay unless a new employer takes the lease on. You also owe the residual at the end, 28.13% of the cost plus GST on a five-year lease (ATO), and provider fees or a marked-up car price can eat the tax saving.
What happens to a novated lease if I change jobs?
The lease does not end: it can move to a new employer that offers salary packaging, or the payments come back to you from after-tax income, which removes the tax benefit. A car loan is unaffected by a job change. Under the draft EV law, changing employers also counts as a new commitment for the FBT concession.
Can I get a novated lease if my employer does not offer salary packaging?
No. A novated lease needs your employer to run the deductions through payroll, usually with a salary packaging provider, and without that the FBT exemption is not available. If your employer does not offer it, a car loan is the option, and the EV discounts some lenders publish are worth checking.
Does a novated lease affect my HELP repayments?
It can. The benefit shows on your income statement as a reportable fringe benefit, worked out as if no exemption applied, and that amount can affect HELP repayments, the Medicare levy surcharge and some government payments. A car loan has no such effect. Check with your accountant if any of these apply to you.
What running costs are included in a novated lease?
A fully maintained novated lease typically includes fuel or charging costs, comprehensive insurance, registration, scheduled servicing, tyres, roadside assistance, and CTP (greenslip). All these costs are bundled into one pre-tax salary deduction. With a car loan you pay them yourself from after-tax income.
Is FBT payable on a novated lease?
For petrol, diesel and plug-in hybrid cars, yes: FBT applies to the private use and is usually covered by post-tax contributions. Battery-electric and hydrogen fuel cell cars under the fuel-efficient luxury car tax threshold ($91,661 for 2026-27) are exempt. Plug-in hybrids lost the exemption from 1 April 2025 unless already under a binding commitment, and Treasury's September 2026 draft law would narrow the EV exemption for commitments from 1 April 2027.
Free, no obligation, one match

Get both quotes and compare them after tax

Get matched with a specialist who can quote a novated lease and show how it compares with a car loan. Free to use, no obligation.

Find a YFG Approved broker
Free to use, no obligation.
Start